Vegetables with useful phytochemicals, vitamins, protein, carbohydrates, and minerals are nutritional sources and play an important role in the prevention of many chronic diseases. However, vegetables are contaminated with potentially toxic elements caused by anthropogenic and natural activities. Therefore, this study is the first attempt to analyze 14 potentially toxic elements in some of the most consumed vegetables in Kastamonu province located in the Western Black Sea Region of Turkey by using an ICP-OES for the evaluation of the potential human health risks of adults due to potentially toxic elements via ingestion. The concentrations (μg/kg, dw) of Fe, Al, Sr, Mn, Zn, Ti, Cu, Ni, Pb, V, As, Cr, Cd, and Co analyzed in sixty-nine samples belonging to thirty-six different vegetable types varied from 3995 to 968073, 569 to 616664, 2730 to 144287, 843 to 51417, 268 to 34344, <LOD to 65115, <LOD to 21506, <LOD to 44230, <LOD to 3671, <LOD to 4582, <LOD to 2996, 198 to 5548, 284 to 1289, and <LOD to 856, respectively. The Pb and Cd concentrations analyzed in the studied vegetable samples were above the maximum levels recommended by the Turkish Food Codex. The hazard index and total cancer risk index were estimated to evaluate noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic health risks, respectively. Evaluation of potential noncarcinogenic risk reveals no risk for consumption of the studied vegetables (except for eggplant, potato, and sugar beet) for adult consumers. However, values of the total cancer risk index estimated for Pb, Ni, Cr, Cd, and As analyzed in 15 vegetable samples are higher than the safety limit (≥10–4).
Mahmud, M. J.; Sharifa, S. M.; Hossain, S.; Sultana, S.; Rahman, M. M. Health risk assessment based on the trace elements in the fruits and vegetables grown in an industrial area in Dhaka city, Bangladesh. J. Hum. Environ. Health. Promot. 2020, 6 (3), 106– 114, DOI: 10.29252/jhehp.6.3.2
El-Ramady, H.; Hajdú, P.; Törős, G.; Badgar, K.; Llanaj, X.; Kiss, A.; Abdalla, N.; Omara, A. E. D.; Elsakhawy, T.; Elbasiouny, H.; Elbehiry, F.; Amer, M.; El-Mahrouk, M. E.; Prokisch, J. Plant nutrition for human health: A pictorial review on plant bioactive compounds for sustainable agriculture. Sustainability 2022, 14 (14), 8329, DOI: 10.3390/su14148329
Ruzaidy, N. I. M.; Amid, A. Heavy metal contamination in vegetables and its detection: A review. Sci. Herit. J. 2020, 4 (1), 1– 5, DOI: 10.26480/gws.01.2020.01.05
Ara, M. H.; Khan, A. R.; Uddin, N.; Dhar, P. K. Health risk assessment of heavy metals in the leafy vegetables, fruit, and root vegetables cultivated near Mongla industrial,area, Bangladesh. J. Hum. Environ. Health. Promot. 2018, 4 (4), 144– 152, DOI: 10.29252/jhehp.4.4.1
Altamemi, R. A. A.; Turhan, Ş.; Kurnaz, A. Natural and anthropogenic radioactivityin some vegetables and fruits commonly consumed in the Western Black Sea Region of Turkey. Radiochim. Acta. 2021, 109 (12), 935– 942, DOI: 10.1515/ract-2021-1100
Chandel, S. S.; Rana, A. S.; Ibrahim, M. Physiological analysis and contamination of heavy metal contents in vegetables and fruits irrigated with wastewater. J. Environ. Anal. Chem. 2021, 8 (3), 1– 5
Alam, M. N. E.; Hosen, M. M.; Ullah, A. K. M. A.; Maksud, M. A.; Khan, S. R.; Lutfa, L. N.; Choudhury, T. R.; Quraishi, S. B. Pollution characteristics, source identification, and health risk of heavy metals in the soil-vegetable system in two districts of Bangladesh. Biol. Trace. Elem. Res. 2023, 201, 4985– 4999, DOI: 10.1007/s12011-023-03558-7
Ebabhi, A.; Adebayo, R. Nutritional values of vegetables. Vegetable crops – Health, benefits and cultivation; IntechOpen, 2022. DOI: DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.101090 .
Turhan, Ş.; Turfan, N.; Kurnaz, A. The heavy metal levels and health risk evaluation in chestnut (Castanea sativa Miller) consumed in Turkey. Int. J. Environ. HealthRes. 2023, 33 (11), 1091– 1101, DOI: 10.1080/09603123.2022.2073984
Apau, J.; Siameh, M. O.; Misszento, J. A.; Gyamfi, O.; Osei-Owusu, J.; KwaansaAnsah, E. E.; Acheampong, A. Determination of potentially toxic elements in selectedvegetables sampled from some markets in the Kumasi metropolis. Cogent Public Health. 2022, 9 (1), 1– 11, DOI: 10.1080/27707571.2022.2145699
Din, I. U.; Muhammad, S.; Rehman, I. U. Heavy metal(loid)s contaminations in soils of Pakistan: a review for the evaluation of human and ecological risks assessment and spatial distribution. Environ. Geochem. Health 2023, 45, 1991– 2012, DOI: 10.1007/s10653-022-01312-x
Ali, W.; Muhammad, S. Compositional data analysis of heavy metal contamination and eco-environmental risks in Himalayan agricultural soils, northern Pakistan. J. Geochem. Explor. 2023, 255, 107323, DOI: 10.1016/j.gexplo.2023.107323
Muhammad, S. Evaluation of heavy metals in water and sediments, pollution, and risk indices of Naltar Lakes, Pakistan. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 2023, 30, 28217– 28226, DOI: 10.1007/s11356-022-24160-9
Khaneghah, A. M.; Fakhri, Y.; Nematollahi, A.; Pirhadi, M. Potentiallytoxicelements (PTEs) in cereal-based foods: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Trends. Food Sci. Technol. 2020, 96, 30– 44, DOI: 10.1016/j.tifs.2019.12.007
Guerra, F.; Trevizam, A. R.; Muraoka, T.; Marcante, N. C.; Canniatti-Brazaca, S. G. Heavy metals in vegetables and potential risk for human health. Sci. Agric. 2012, 69 (1), 54– 60, DOI: 10.1590/S0103-90162012000100008
Gupta, S. K.; Chabukdhara, M.; Singh, J.; Bux, F. Evaluation and potential health hazard of selected metals in water, sediments, and fish from the Gomti River. Human. Ecol. Risk Assess. 2015, 21, 227– 240, DOI: 10.1080/10807039.2014.902694
Chabukdhara, M.; Gupta, S. K.; Kotecha, Y.; Nema, A. K. Groundwater quality in Ghaziabad district, Uttar Pradesh, India: Multivariate and health risk assessment. Chemosphere 2017, 179, 167– 178, DOI: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2017.03.086
Gupta, S. K.; Ansari, F. A.; Nasr, M.; Chabukdhara, M.; Bux, F. Multivariate analysis and health risk assessment of heavy metal contents in foodstuffs of Durban, South Africa. Environ. Monit. Assess. 2018, 190 (3), 1– 15, DOI: 10.1007/s10661-018-6546-1
Mutiyar, P. K.; Gupta, S. K.; Mittal, A. K. Fate of pharmaceutical active compounds (PhACs) from River Yamuna, India: An ecotoxicological risk assessment approach. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 2018, 150, 297– 304, DOI: 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2017.12.041
Baruah, S. G.; Ahmed, I.; Das, B.; Ingtipi, B.; Boruah, H.; Gupta, S. K.; Nema, A. K.; Chabukdhara, M. Heavy metal(loid)s contamination and health risk assessment of soil-rice system in rural and peri-urban areas of lower Brahmaputra valley, northeast India. Chemosphere 2021, 266, 129150, DOI: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.129150
Muhammad, S.; Usman, Q. A. Heavy metal contamination in water of Indus River and its tributaries, Northern Pakistan: evaluation for potential risk and source apportionment. Toxin Rev. 2022, 41 (2), 380– 388, DOI: 10.1080/15569543.2021.1882499
Kollander, B.; Rodushkin, I.; Sundström, B. Multi-element assessment ofpotentially toxic and essential elements in new and traditional food varieties in Sweden. Foods 2023, 12, 1831, DOI: 10.3390/foods12091831
Islam, M.; Islam, A.; Phoungthong, K.; Ustaoğlu, F.; Tokatli, C.; Ahmed, R.; Ibrahim, K. A.; Idris, A. M. Potentially toxic elements in vegetable and ricespecies in Bangladesh and their exposure assessment. J. Food Compos. Anal. 2022, 106, 104350, DOI: 10.1016/j.jfca.2021.104350
Cherfi, A.; Cherfi, M.; Maache-Rezzoug, Z.; Rezzoug, S. A. Risk assessment of heavy metals via consumption of vegetables collected from different supermarkets in La Rochelle, France. Environ. Monit. Assess. 2016, 188, 1– 10, DOI: 10.1007/s10661-016-5140-7
Avila, P. F.; Ferreira-da-Silva, E.; Candeias, C. Health risk assessment through consumption of vegetables rich in heavy metals: The case study of the surrounding villages from Panasqueira mine Central Portugal. Environ. Geochem. Health. 2017, 39, 565– 589, DOI: 10.1007/s10653-016-9834-0
Zhong, T.; Xue, D.; Zhao, L.; Zhang, X. Concentration of heavy metals invegetables and potential health risk assessment in China. Environ. Geochem. Health. 2018, 40 (1), 313– 322, DOI: 10.1007/s10653-017-9909-6
Ghasemidehkordi, B.; Malekirad, A. A.; Nazem, H.; Fazilati, M.; Salavati, H.; Shariatifar, N.; Rezaei, M.; Fakhri, Y.; Khaneghah, A. M. Concentration of lead andmercury in collected vegetables and herbs from Markazi province, Iran: A non-carcinogenic risk assessment. Food Chem. Toxicol. 2018, 113, 204– 210, DOI: 10.1016/j.fct.2018.01.048
Pipoyan, D.; Beglaryan, M.; Stepanyan, S.; Merendino, N. Dietary exposure assessment of potentially toxic trace elements in fruits and vegetables sold in Town of Kapan, Armenia. Biol. Trace Elem. Res. 2019, 190, 234– 241, DOI: 10.1007/s12011-018-1522-8
Manea, D. N.; Ienciu, A. A.; Ştef, R.; Şmuleac, I. L.; Gergen, I. I.; Nica, D. V. Health risk assessment of dietary heavy metals intake from fruits and vegetables grown in selected old mining areas─a case study: The Banat Area of Southern Carpathians. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health. 2020, 17, 5172, DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17145172
Iriabije, T. O.; Uwadiae, S. Analysis of some heavy metal contents in selected vegetables and fruits from states in Nigeria. Am. J. Bio. Sci. 2020, 8 (2), 37– 40, DOI: 10.11648/j.ajbio.20200802.12
Kandil, M. A.; Khorshed, M. A.; Saleh, I. A.; Eshmawy, M. R. Investigation of heavy metals in fruits and vegetables and their potential risk for Egyptian consumer health. Plant Arch. 2020, 20 (1), 1453– 1463
Bayissa, L. D.; Gebeyehu, H. R. Vegetables contamination by heavy metals and associated health risk to the population in Koka area of central Ethiopia. PLoS One 2021, 16 (7), e0254236, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0254236
Alain, T. K.; Luc, B. T.; Ali, D.; Moumoni, D.; Zongo, I.; Zougmore, F. Assessment of heavy metal concentration and evaluation of health risk of some vegetables cultivated in Loumbila Farmland, Burkina Faso. J. Environ. Prot. 2021, 12, 1019– 1032, DOI: 10.4236/jep.2021.1212060
Alsafran, M.; Usman, K.; Rizwan, M.; Ahmed, T.; Al Jabri, H. The carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health risks of metal(oid)s bioaccumulation in leafy vegetables: A consumption advisory. Front. Environ. Sci. 2021, 9, 1– 11, DOI: 10.3389/fenvs.2021.742269
Jehan, S.; Muhammad, S.; Ali, W.; Hussain, M. L. Potential risks assessment of heavy metal(loid)s contaminated vegetables in Pakistan: A review. Geocarto Int. 2022, 37 (24), 7287– 7302, DOI: 10.1080/10106049.2021.1969449
Gupta, N.; Yadav, K. K.; Kumar, V.; Prasad, S.; Cabral-Pinto, M. M. S.; Jeon, B. H.; Kumar, S.; Abdellattif, M. H.; Alsukaibia, A. K. D. Investigation of heavy metal accumulation in vegetables and health risk to humans from their consumption. Front. Environ. Sci. 2022, 10, 1– 5, DOI: 10.3389/fenvs.2022.791052
Wódkowska, A.; Gruszecka-Kosowska, A. Dietary exposure to potentially harmful elements in edible plants in Poland and the health risk dynamics related to their geochemical differentiation. Sci. Rep. 2023, 13, 1– 17, DOI: 10.1038/s41598-023-35647-x
Najmi, A.; Albratty, M.; Al-Rajab, A. J.; Alhazmi, H. A.; Javed, S. A.; Ahsan, W.; Rehman, Z. U.; Hassani, R.; Alqahtani, S. S. Heavy metal contamination in leafy vegetables grown in Jazan region of Saudi Arabia: Assessment of possible human health hazards. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public. Health. 2023, 20 (4), 2984, DOI: 10.3390/ijerph20042984
Martín-León, V.; Rubio, C.; Rodríguez-Hernández, A.; Zumbado, M.; Acosta-Dacal, A.; Henríquez-Hernández, L. A.; Boada, L. D.; Travieso-Aja, M. d. M.; Luzardo, O. P. Evaluation of essential, toxic and potentially toxic elements in leafy vegetables grown in the Canary Islands. Toxics 2023, 11, 1– 21, DOI: 10.3390/toxics11050442
Türkdoğan, M. K.; Kilicel, F.; Kara, K.; Tuncer, I.; Uygan, İ. Heavy metals in soil, vegetables and fruits in the endemic upper gastrointestinal cancer region of Turkey. Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 2003, 13 (3), 175– 179, DOI: 10.1016/S1382-6689(02)00156-4
DEMIREZEN, D.; AKSOY, A. Heavy metal levels in vegetables in Turkey are within safe limits for Cu, Zn, Ni and exceeded for Cd and Pb. J. Food Qual. 2006, 29, 252– 265, DOI: 10.1111/j.1745-4557.2006.00072.x
Osma, E.; Serin, M.; Leblebici, Z. Investigation of heavy metals accumulatıon in some vegetables grown in Şile (Istanbul). Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü Dergisi. 2013, 6 (2), 267– 275, (in Turkish)
Leblebici, Z.; Özyürek, F. Ni, Cu and Pb accumulation in vegetables irrigated with different water sources in Nevşehir. Erzincan Univ J. Sci. Technol. 2017, 10 (2), 184– 195
İslamoğlu, A. H.; Kahvecioğlu, T.; Bönce, G.; Gedik, E.; Güneş, F. E. Determination of heavy metals in some fruits, vegetables and fish by ICP-MS. Eurasian J. Food Sci. Technol. 2021, 5 (1), 67– 76
Zor, M.; Kocaoba, S. Determination of metal contents in some green leafy vegetables in Marmara region of Turkey. SN Appl. Sci. 2023, 5 (6), 1– 15, DOI: 10.1007/s42452-023-05369-w
Kurnaz, A.; Turhan, Ş.; Alzaridi, F.; Bakır, T. K. Radiological and physicochemical properties of drinking waters consumed in the Western Black Sea Region of Turkey. J. Radioanal Nucl. Chem. 2021, 328, 805– 814, DOI: 10.1007/s10967-021-07736-6
Turhan, Ş.; Kurnaz, A. Potentially toxic element contamination and health risk assessment in bottled mineral waters consumed in Turkey. Int. J. Environ. Health Res. 2023, 33 (12), 1546– 1557, DOI: 10.1080/09603123.2022.2105825
Pirhadi, M.; Alikord, M.; Tajdar-oranj, B.; Khaniki, G. J.; Nazmara, S.; Fathabad, A. E.; Ghalhari, M. R.; Sadighara, P. Potential toxic elements (PTEs) concentration in wheat and flour products in Iran: A probabilistic risk assessment. Heliyon 2022, 8 (11), e11803, DOI: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e11803
Miletić, A.; Lućić, M.; Onjia, A. Exposure factors in health risk assessment of heavy metal(loid)s in soil and sediment. Metals 2023, 13 (7), 1266, DOI: 10.3390/met13071266
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency). Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund, Volume I. Human Health Evaluation Manual Part A, Interim Final (EPA/540/1-89/002); United States Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, USA, 1989.
TUIK (Turkish Statistical Institute) (2023). Web page https://data.tuik.gov.tr/Bulten/Index?p=Bitkisel-Uretim-Istatistikleri-2022.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency). 2012. Integrated Risk Information System. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC. Web page: https://iris.epa.gov/AtoZ/?list_type=alpha.
Pazalja, M.; Sulejmanović, J.; Begić, S.; Salihović, M. Heavy metals content andhealth risk assessment of selected leafy plants consumed in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Plant, Soil and Environ, Czech Academy of Agric. Sci. 2023, 69 (4), 170– 178, DOI: 10.17221/42/2023-PSE
Goren, A. Y.; Genisoglu, M.; Kazancı, Y.; Sofuoglu, S. C. Countrywide spatial variation of potentially toxic element contamination in soils of Turkey and assessment of population health risks for nondietary ingestion. ACS Omega. 2022, 7 (41), 36457– 36467, DOI: 10.1021/acsomega.2c04261
R Core Team R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org/. (accessed 2023).
Demsar, J.; Curk, T.; Erjavec, A.; Gorup, C.; Hocevar, T.; Milutinovic, M.; Mozina, M.; Polajnar, M.; Toplak, M.; Staric, A.; Stajdohar, M.; Umek, L.; Zagar, L.; Zbontar, J.; Zitnik, M.; Zupan, B. Orange: Data Mining Toolbox in Python. J. Mach. Learn Res. 2013, 14, 2349– 2353
Yadav, P. K.; Singh, A. K. A review of iron overload in beta-thalassemia major, And a discussion on alternative potent iron chelation targets. Plasmatology 2022, 16, 1– 9, DOI: 10.1177/26348535221103560
Al-Naseem, A.; Sallam, A.; Choudhury, S.; Thachil, J. Iron deficiency withoutanaemia: a diagnosis that matters. Clin. Med. 2021, 21 (2), 107– 113, DOI: 10.7861/clinmed.2020-0582
Bondy, S. C. Low levels of aluminum can lead to behavioral and morphological changes associated with Alzheimer’s disease and age-related neurodegeneration. Neurotoxicology. 2016, 52, 222– 229, DOI: 10.1016/j.neuro.2015.12.002
Basu, R.; Mukhopadhyay, A.; Ray, S. S.; Chakrabarti, P.; Ram, S. S.; Sudarshan, M.; Chakrabarti, S. Elevated strontium concentration in the blood of automobile workers in Kolkata. Progress in Health Sci. 2014, 4, 186– 189
Kulshreshtha, D.; Ganguly, J.; Jog, M. Manganese and movement disorders: A review. J. Mov. Disord. 2021, 14 (2), 93– 102, DOI: 10.14802/jmd.20123
Chasapis, C. T.; Ntoupa, P. S. A.; Spiliopoulou, C. A.; Stefanidou, M. E. Recent aspects of the effects of zinc on human health. Arch. Toxicol. 2020, 94 (5), 1443– 1460, DOI: 10.1007/s00204-020-02702-9
Nematollahi, A.; Abdi, L.; Abdi-Moghadam, Z.; Fakhri, Y.; Borzoei, M.; Tajdar oranj, B.; Thai, V. M.; Linh, N. T. T.; Khaneghah, A. M. The concentration of potentially toxic elements (PTEs) in sausages: a systematic review and meta-analysis study. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 2021, 28, 55186– 55201, DOI: 10.1007/s11356-021-14879-2
Tibau, A. V.; Grube, B. D.; Velez, B. J.; Vega, V. M.; Mutter, J. Titanium exposure and human health. Oral Sci. Int. 2019, 16, 15– 24, DOI: 10.1002/osi2.1001
Taylor, A. A.; Tsuji, J. S.; Garry, M. R.; McArdle, M. E.; Goodfellow, W. L., Jr; Adams, W. J.; Menzie, C. A. Critical review of exposure and effects: implications for setting regulatory health criteria for ingested copper. Environ. Manage. 2020, 65 (1), 131– 159, DOI: 10.1007/s00267-019-01234-y
Genchi, G.; Carocci, A.; Lauria, G.; Sinicropi, M. S.; Catalano, A. Nickel: Humanhealth and environmental toxicology. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health. 2020, 17 (3), 679, DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17030679
García-Lestón, J.; Méndez, J.; Pásaro, E.; Laffon, B. Genotoxic effects of lead: An updated review. Environ. Int. 2010, 36 (6), 623– 636, DOI: 10.1016/j.envint.2010.04.011
WHO (World Health Organization). Joint FAO/WHO Joint Expert Committee on General standard for contaminants and toxins in food and feed. CXS 193-1995, WHO, Geneva, 1995.
EC (European Commission). 2006. Commission Regulation No: 1881/2006. Setting maximum levels for certain contaminants in foodstuffs. Off. J. Eur. Communities L 364/5, 20.12.2006. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2006:364:0005:0024:EN:PDF.
OG (Official Gazette). Turkish Food Codex on maximum limits of contains in foods. Official Gazette No. 26879 , 17 May 2008.
Wilk, A.; Szypulska-Koziarska, D.; Wiszniewska, B. The toxicity of vanadium on gastrointestinal, urinary and reproductive system, and its influence on fertility and fetuses malformations. Postepy. HigMed. Dosw. 2017, 71, 850– 859
Suh, M.; Wikoff, D.; Lipworth, L.; Goodman, M.; Fitch, S.; Mittal, L.; Ring, C.; Proctor, D. Hexavalent chromium and stomach cancer: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 2019, 49 (2), 140– 159, DOI: 10.1080/10408444.2019.1578730
WHO (World Health Organization). Chromium in drinking-water, background document for development of WHO Guidelines for drinking-water. WHO/SDE/WSH/03.04/04, WHO, Geneva, 2003.
Martinez, V. D.; Vucic, E. A.; Becker-Santos, D. D.; Gil, L.; Lam, W. L. Arsenic exposure and the induction of human cancers. J. Toxicol. 2011, 2011, 1– 14, DOI: 10.1155/2011/431287
Furtak, G.; Kozłowski, M.; Kwiatkowski, S.; Cymbaluk-Płoska, A. The role of lead and cadmium in gynecological malignancies. Antioxidants 2022, 11 (12), 2468, DOI: 10.3390/antiox11122468
Leyssens, L.; Vinck, B.; Van Der Straeten, C.; Wuyts, F.; Maes, L. Cobalt toxicity in humans-A review of the potential sources and systemic health effects. Toxicology 2017, 387, 43– 56, DOI: 10.1016/j.tox.2017.05.015